About

The Original P&M Pizza House opened in 1947. Originally located across the street, Lefty & Mooney Martz moved into the property where we are located today (1609 5th Ave. - Arnold, PA) after establishing their business. Our property, which used to be home of "THE STAR" Movie Theater has housed many generations of the P&M Pizza recipe. In 2004, the P&M Pizza tradition ended until the McKinley Family reopened the doors in 2008 after several major renovations. The McKinley Family which has family ties to the original owner Mooney Martz reopened the historic pizza shop to bring back the long time recipe that people from Western Pennsylvania and other parts of the world crave.

The McKinley Family is proud to serve this unique one of a kind recipe that isn't available in any other pizza shop across the country. We have dedicated our time to providing our customers a quality experience during every visit with hot and delicious pizza, cold beer, and a family-friendly and non-smoking atmosphere.

https://archive.triblive.com/news/old-favorite-returns-to-fifth-avenue-in-arnold/